WTO国际责任的形式可否选择——法律权利与政策选择Can International Duties in WTO Be Chosen?——Choice of Legal Rights and Polices
张军旗;
摘要(Abstract)：
在WTO违法之诉中,违法成员的首要责任是撤销违法措施,违法成员没有任意选择不同责任形式的法律权利。实践中,违法成员可能选择给予申诉方补偿或宁愿承受报复而拒不撤销违法措施,这对WTO协议的履行会产生消极影响,但在非常情况下也会对成员主权形成一种保护。
关键词(KeyWords)： WTO;国际责任;责任形式;国家主权
基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金青年项目“WTO体制中的国际法律责任制度研究”(05CFX033)。
作者(Author): 张军旗;
Email:
DOI:
参考文献(References)：
- [1]Judith H.Bello,The WTO Dispute Settlement Understanding:Less is More,90The American Journal International Law416,No.3,1996,pp.416-417.
- [2]赵维田.世贸组织的法律制度[M].长春:吉林人民出版社,2000.484.
- [3]Judith H.Bello,Book Reviews:The Jurisprudence of GATT&the WTO:Insight on Treaty Law and Economics Relations,95The American Journal International Law984,Oct.2001,p.988.
- [4][美]约翰.H.杰克逊.GATT/WTO法理与实践[M].张玉卿,等译.北京:新华出版社,2002.189.
- [5]See Alan O.Sykes,The Remedy for Breach of Obligations under the WTO Dispute Settlement Understanding:Damages or Specific Performance?in M.Bronckers and R.Quick(eds.),New Directions in International Law,Kluwer Law International Ltd.,2000,pp.349-351.
- [6][7]Alan O.Sykes,The Remedy for Breach of Obligations under the WTO Dispute Settlement Understanding:Damages or Specific Performance?in M.Bronckers and R.Quick(eds.),New Directions in International Law,Kluwer Law International Ltd.,2000,pp.354-355;pp.355-356.
- [8][9][10][11][12]See John H.Jackson,International Law Status of WTO Dispute Settlement Reports:Obligation to Comply or Option to“Buy Out”?98The American Journal International Law109,January2004,113;117;118;119;119-121;122-123;123.
- [13]Sungjoon Cho,The Nature of Remedies in International Trade Law,65University of Pittsburgh Law Review763,summer2004,p.784.
- [14]John.H.Jackson.Testimony Before the Senate Finance Committee,March23,1994,Legal Problems of International Economic Relations,3rd ed.,West Publishing Co.,1995,p.305.
- [15]SAA,p.366et seq.See Report of the Panel,United States-Section301-310of the Trade Act of1974,WT/DS152/R.陈安.国际经济法论丛(第四卷)[C].北京:法律出版社,2001.112-113.
- [16]WTO Doc.,WT/DS/OV/24,15June2005.